Header Photo Image1

The 1991 BSI Dinner group photo

The 137th anniversary of the Master’s birth included all of our traditional rites and ceremonies. Joan [Mrs. Benton] Wood was honored as The Woman. The busy program featured John Bennett Shaw’s paean to the late Commissionaire, Dr. Julian Wolff, read in Mr. Shaw’s absence by Richard Schull. Robert N. Brodie mused on “what ever happened to” a number of well-known Canonical characters. Don Yates proffered two reader’s digested versions of The Hound of the Baskervilles (one sixty seconds long, the other five words long), and Wayne Swift essayed a portion of his ongoing scholarship concerning Silver Blaze. Bill Rabe acquainted members with the shocking results of his investigations into the BSI’s unofficial anthem, “Aunt Clara” (proving that all these years we’ve been singing it to the wrong tune — a Scottish folk song called “Mush Mush”). Norman Davis plunged the “art” of the pun to a new nadir in his survey of Sherlockian horse-racing handicapping. Don Redmond was given The Good Old Index Award honoring his 21 years of indexing of the Baker Street Journal. David Musto gave a lucid account of the founding of the first Sherlockian society in the Soviet Union, The Red-Headed League of Moscow, a long-awaited event in which Mr. Musto lent a gently guiding hand. The report in the BSJ states, “The Baker Street Irregulars wish every good fortune to these new-found Soviet friends.”

However, 1991 will forever be remembered in the annals of BSI history for the Sherlockian Cocktail Party on the following day.  At the Cocktail Party, Tom Stix formally opened the BSI to women in announcing seven additional BSI Investitures, six of whom were women.  His emotional announcement can be heard below.  Two of these Investitures went to Katherine McMahon (one of the original solvers of the Sherlock Holmes Crossword Puzzle) and Edwin V. King (who had earned the honor in the 1940s).  Next, he bestowed an Investiture on Dame Jean Conan Doyle (Arthur Conan Doyle’s daughter).  Stix then went on to invest Edith Meiser, Julia Carlson Rosenblatt, Evelyn Herzog, and Susan Rice.  He ended his moving presentation by emphasizing that these were genuine Investitures in the Baker Street Irregulars, entitling the women to invitations to the Annual Dinner.  His announcement was interrupted by several standing ovations. History had turned, and the BSI Dinner was now co-ed.

Also at the Sherlockian cocktail party, the Commissionaire’s Award for outstanding contributions to Sherlockiana was conferred upon H. George Fletcher who, in his capacity of Director of Fordham University Press, had served for sixteen years as publisher of the Baker Street Journal and of a number of important Sherlockian books including the first volumes of the Baker Street Irregulars’ History Project. (See the 1988 BSI Dinner for background on this award.)

Dinner Details: January 11, 1991
24 Fifth Avenue, New York

Dinner Photo Information

Click on the above photo to see a larger version of it, and maximize your browser window to see the most detail.

Key to People in the 1991 BSI Dinner photo (PDF)

BSI Honours List

Dame Jean Conan Doyle as A Certain Gracious Lady*
Henry Enberg as John Garrideb
Evelyn A. Herzog as The Daintiest Thing Under a Bonnet*
Roger Johnson as Pall Mall Gazette*
Edwin V. King as Captain Arthur Morstan*
Katherine McMahon as Lucy Ferrier*
Edith Meiser as A Fascinating and Beautiful Woman*
Glen Miranker as The Origin of Tree Worship
Joseph W. Moran as Sir Augustus Moran, C.B.
William Nadel as Bartholomew Sholto
Susan Rice as Beeswing*
Julia Carlson Rosenblatt as Mrs. Turner*
CharlesJ. Shields as 17 King Edward Street
Stephen H. Tolins as John Straker
* received Investiture at another event during the year
What is an Investiture?

Two-Shilling Award:
Ely M. Liebow
What is a Two-Shilling Award?

The Woman:
Joan [Mrs. Benton] Wood
What is The Woman honour?

"Stand with me here upon the terrace..."
(as named at this Dinner, not their year of passing)
Not listed in the 1991 BSJ report.
What is the origin of “standing on the terrace?”

Morley-Montgomery Award:
No awards were given from 1981-1995.
What is the Morley-Montgomery Award?

Reports on the Dinner 

The Baker Street Journal v41 n1 (March 1991) pp. 45, 49 (available in the eBSJ).

Blau, Peter, Scuttlebutt from the Spermaceti Press, (January 1991), p. 2.

List of 1991 BSI Dinner Attendees (PDF, part of Key to Dinner photo)


Thomas L. Stix, BSI
Thomas Stix at a BSI Dinner

Thomas L. Stix, Jr. (The Norwood Builder) became the head of the BSI (Wiggins) after the 1986 BSI Dinner.  He served in that capacity until 1997.  At the 1991 Sherlockian Cocktail Party on the day after the 1991 BSI Dinner, Stix invested six women into the BSI to great applause.  He said that, henceforth, female BSI would be invited to the Annual Dinner. You can hear his moving presentation in this 12-minute vignette from the 1991 Sherlockian Cocktail Party.  Stix (whose father was also a BSI member) was invested at the 1961 BSI Dinner.

Click to play this recording

Recordings of both the 1991 BSI Dinner and Sherlockian Cocktail Reception are available at Harvard as part of the BSI Archive.

Related Material

1991 BSI Dinner Menu (digitized images at Harvard)
Two pages. Cover and interior. Sequence 138-139.

Ticket to the Annual Sherlockian Cocktail Party on January 12, 1991 (digitized image at Harvard)
One page. Sequence 140

Rosenblatt, Albert, Rhyming Retrospective of the 1991 BSI Festivities (digitized image at Harvard)
Presented at the Saturday Sherlockian Cocktail Party.
Two pages. Sequence 141-142.

I Hear of Sherlock Everywhere, Episode 89: The Adventuresses of Sherlock Holmes
In this episode of their podcast, W. Scott Monty, BSI and Burt Wolder, BSI interview Evelyn Herzog, ASH, BSI and Susan Rice, ASH, BSI (both among the first women invested in the BSI in 1991) about the events leading up to the admittance of women in the BSI.  This link goes directly to the point in the podcast when they talk about the 1991 Sherlockian Cocktail Party and Tom Stix’s announcement.

Previous dinner: the 1990 BSI Dinner

Next dinner: the 1992 BSI Dinner

For an index to all BSI Dinners and photos, see our BSI Dinner Summary list.

The BSI Archive is located at the Houghton Library at Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts. Archival material may be used by any qualified scholar, subject to the normal rules and regulations of the Library. For links to a detailed finding aid and related information, see our BSI Archive at Harvard page.

Page composed on 4/30/2016 by Andrew Solberg.
This page last updated 4/30/2016 by Andrew Solberg.